Agios Panteleimon at Upper Mastoratika appears in the catalogue of 1739; by 1754 it is recorded as completely destroyed, and what stands today is its rebuilding.

A description made in the 1880s gives the church as it was before the modern repairs. Twelve steps lead up in front of it to the cemetery, through what the visitor called a kind of portico with three arches, with grave monuments beneath it and a stair up to the gallery. In the middle is set a slab carved with a double-headed eagle. The bell hung on a chain from an olive tree. Inside there was a stone iconostasis with old icons on a gold ground, badly decayed wall paintings in the sanctuary, and on the small altar of the saint an elegant brass double candlestick with a parrot perched between the two candles.

From the road above the church there is a fine view down over Loggos.

Feast day: 27 July.

It is also one of the very few churches on Paxos that is sometimes found unlocked, and when it is, a small side door lets you up into the gallery.